Top Reasons for RFEs in Concurrent I-140 & I-485 Filings can be quite frustrating for applicants navigating the complex U.S. immigration system. Understanding why these Requests for Evidence (RFEs) occur is crucial to avoid delays and improve your chances of approval. In this article, we’ll explore the most common causes of RFEs when filing the I-140 immigrant petition and I-485 adjustment of status concurrently, helping you prepare a stronger case and reduce the risk of additional requests from USCIS.
Common Documentation Issues Leading to RFEs,
Employment Verification and Employer-Related RFEs,
Evidence of Eligibility and Supporting Documents,
Filing Errors and Procedural Mistakes,
How to Respond Effectively to RFEs,
Tips to Avoid RFEs in Future Filings,
Understanding Concurrent I-140 & I-485 Filings
Before diving into the top reasons for RFEs in concurrent I-140 & I-485 filings, it’s important to grasp what concurrent filing means. When an applicant files Form I-140 (Immigrant Petition for Alien Worker) and Form I-485 (Application to Register Permanent Residence or Adjust Status) at the same time, they are essentially asking USCIS to process both the employment-based petition and the adjustment of status simultaneously. This can speed up the green card process but also increases scrutiny, leading to more frequent RFEs if the evidence isn’t airtight.
USCIS taking too long? Discover how a Mandamus lawsuit can get your case moving.
Common Documentation Issues Leading to RFEs
One of the biggest triggers for RFEs in concurrent filings is incomplete or inconsistent documentation. USCIS officers want to see clear, verifiable proof that the applicant meets all eligibility criteria. Missing or unclear documents can cause confusion and delay.
- Incomplete Forms: Forgetting to fill out all required fields or submitting outdated versions of forms.
- Missing Supporting Evidence: Lack of essential documents like birth certificates, marriage certificates, or proof of lawful entry.
- Inconsistent Information: Discrepancies between the I-140 and I-485 forms, such as different names, dates, or job titles.
Employment Verification and Employer-Related RFEs
Since the I-140 petition is employer-driven, many RFEs arise from issues related to the employer’s ability to pay the offered wage or the legitimacy of the job offer itself.
- Financial Evidence: Employers must prove they can pay the offered wage from the priority date onward, usually through tax returns, annual reports, or audited financial statements.
- Job Offer Validity: USCIS may question whether the job offer is genuine and permanent, especially if the employer is new or has a history of immigration violations.
- Position Requirements: RFEs often request clarification on whether the applicant meets the educational and experience requirements stated in the labor certification or petition.
Evidence of Eligibility and Supporting Documents
Another common cause of RFEs is insufficient proof that the applicant qualifies under the specific immigrant category. For example, if you’re applying under an EB-2 or EB-3 category, USCIS will want to see clear evidence of your education, work experience, and any required licenses or certifications.
- Educational Credentials: Diplomas, transcripts, and evaluations of foreign degrees must be submitted and properly authenticated.
- Work Experience Letters: Detailed letters from previous employers describing job duties, dates of employment, and skills gained.
- Licenses and Certifications: If the job requires special licenses, these must be current and verifiable.
Filing Errors and Procedural Mistakes
Sometimes, RFEs are triggered by simple filing errors that can be easily avoided with careful review.
- Incorrect Fees: Submitting the wrong filing fee or failing to include payment can cause an RFE.
- Missing Signatures: USCIS requires signatures on all forms; missing signatures are a common reason for RFEs.
- Improper Filing Location: Sending your application package to the wrong USCIS service center can delay processing and prompt an RFE.
How to Respond Effectively to RFEs
Receiving an RFE can feel overwhelming, but it’s important to respond thoroughly and promptly. Here are some tips to handle RFEs like a pro:
- Read the RFE Carefully: Understand exactly what USCIS is requesting and why.
- Gather Complete Evidence: Provide clear, organized, and relevant documents that directly address the RFE points.
- Consult an Immigration Attorney: Legal advice can make a huge difference in crafting a strong response.
- Meet Deadlines: Submit your response within the timeframe given to avoid denial.
Tips to Avoid RFEs in Future Filings
Prevention is better than cure, right? Here are some practical tips to minimize the chance of RFEs in your concurrent filings:
- Double-Check All Forms: Ensure every form is complete, accurate, and signed.
- Organize Your Evidence: Submit clear, well-labeled supporting documents that directly prove eligibility.
- Maintain Consistency: Make sure all information matches across forms and supporting evidence.
- Stay Updated: Use the latest USCIS forms and follow current filing instructions.
- Seek Professional Help: An experienced immigration attorney can help you avoid common pitfalls.
- Understanding the top reasons for RFEs in concurrent I-140 & I-485 filings helps you prepare a stronger application.
- Common RFEs stem from documentation gaps, employer verification issues, and filing errors.
- Careful organization, consistency, and professional guidance can significantly reduce RFE risks.
- Responding promptly and thoroughly to RFEs is critical to keep your green card process on track.
Conclusion
Facing an RFE during your concurrent I-140 and I-485 filing can feel like hitting a roadblock on your immigration journey. But remember, it’s not the end—just a sign to pause, gather more evidence, and clarify your case. Early legal assistance can make all the difference, turning confusion into clarity and delays into approvals. Don’t hesitate to seek help and stay proactive. Your green card dream is within reach!